For most small moves, a cargo van is the better rental than a pickup truck. A van's enclosed cargo area protects furniture and boxes from rain and wind, holds more stacked containers, and locks. A pickup truck is better for tall, dirty or awkward items — a dresser plus a mattress, yard equipment, or a single large appliance — when the weather is dry and the trip is short.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Factor | Cargo van | Pickup truck |
|---|---|---|
| Weather protection | Fully enclosed | Open bed (tarps help, but not much) |
| Security | Locks | Open — not safe to leave loaded |
| Usable volume | Larger (roughly a studio's worth) | Smaller; bed is about 5.5 to 8 ft long |
| Loading height | Low floor, side and rear doors | Higher tailgate lift |
| Tall items | Limited by roof height | No height limit |
| Tie-down needs | Minimal | Every item must be strapped |
| Best for | Boxes, totes, small apartments | Bulky single pieces, outdoor gear |
When a Cargo Van Wins
- Studio or small 1-bedroom moves with mostly boxes or totes plus a bed and a few pieces of furniture.
- Any day with rain or snow — which, in Chicago and Milwaukee, is often.
- Multiple stops where you'll leave the vehicle unattended.
- Moving fragile items that shouldn't be exposed to wind or road debris.
Uniform totes are especially efficient in a van: they stack in solid rows to the ceiling, with no crushed corners.
When a Pickup Truck Wins
- Hauling one or two big items, like a sofa from a Marketplace sale or a new mattress.
- Tall furniture that won't fit under a van roof.
- Dirty or outdoor items — grills, mowers, patio furniture.
- Short trips in dry weather.
Always strap items down with ratchet straps and cover with a tarp; anything loose in a pickup bed can become a highway hazard.
Cost Considerations
Both are usually rented by the day or by a short time block, often with a per-mile charge. Watch for:
- Mileage fees on round trips
- Fuel return requirements
- Insurance or damage waivers
- Equipment add-ons (dolly, blankets)
What If You Need More Space?
If your load won't fit in one van trip, compare two van trips against a 10–15 ft box truck. A box truck is often cheaper than multiple van trips once you count mileage and time. See our complete DIY moving guide for sizing.
Tips for Loading a Cargo Van
- Put the heaviest items against the bulkhead behind the seats.
- Stack totes or boxes in tight rows, heaviest on the bottom.
- Stand mattresses on edge along one side.
- Use tie-down points and straps — vans have them on the floor and walls.
- Keep a clear line to the rear doors so the last-in items come out first.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a cargo van big enough to move a studio apartment?
Often, yes — especially if you pack in uniform containers and have only a bed, a small sofa and a few pieces of furniture.
Can you move a mattress in a cargo van?
Yes. Stand it on its long edge along one wall and strap it in place.
Is a pickup truck good for moving?
For a few bulky items on a dry day, yes. For a full apartment, an enclosed van or box truck is safer and holds more.
How many moving totes fit in a cargo van?
It depends on the van size and furniture, but uniform totes stacked four to five high can fill most of a van's floor space efficiently.
Whatever you drive, pack in containers that stack. Nice Totes delivers 27-gallon totes, a dolly and free pickup across Chicago's north and northwest suburbs and southeast Wisconsin.
View Residential PricingQuestions about sizing, coverage, or what's included? Check our FAQ page or email info@nicetotesrental.com.