Servicing Chicago's Northeast & Northwest Suburbs — Cook, Lake & McHenry County, IL — and Southeast Wisconsin — Kenosha, Racine & Milwaukee County, WI

Cargo Van vs Pickup Truck for Moving: Which Should You Rent?

For most small moves, a cargo van is the better rental than a pickup truck. A van's enclosed cargo area protects furniture and boxes from rain and wind, holds more stacked containers, and locks. A pickup truck is better for tall, dirty or awkward items — a dresser plus a mattress, yard equipment, or a single large appliance — when the weather is dry and the trip is short.

Side-by-Side Comparison

FactorCargo vanPickup truck
Weather protectionFully enclosedOpen bed (tarps help, but not much)
SecurityLocksOpen — not safe to leave loaded
Usable volumeLarger (roughly a studio's worth)Smaller; bed is about 5.5 to 8 ft long
Loading heightLow floor, side and rear doorsHigher tailgate lift
Tall itemsLimited by roof heightNo height limit
Tie-down needsMinimalEvery item must be strapped
Best forBoxes, totes, small apartmentsBulky single pieces, outdoor gear

When a Cargo Van Wins

  • Studio or small 1-bedroom moves with mostly boxes or totes plus a bed and a few pieces of furniture.
  • Any day with rain or snow — which, in Chicago and Milwaukee, is often.
  • Multiple stops where you'll leave the vehicle unattended.
  • Moving fragile items that shouldn't be exposed to wind or road debris.

Uniform totes are especially efficient in a van: they stack in solid rows to the ceiling, with no crushed corners.

When a Pickup Truck Wins

  • Hauling one or two big items, like a sofa from a Marketplace sale or a new mattress.
  • Tall furniture that won't fit under a van roof.
  • Dirty or outdoor items — grills, mowers, patio furniture.
  • Short trips in dry weather.

Always strap items down with ratchet straps and cover with a tarp; anything loose in a pickup bed can become a highway hazard.

Cost Considerations

Both are usually rented by the day or by a short time block, often with a per-mile charge. Watch for:

  • Mileage fees on round trips
  • Fuel return requirements
  • Insurance or damage waivers
  • Equipment add-ons (dolly, blankets)

What If You Need More Space?

If your load won't fit in one van trip, compare two van trips against a 10–15 ft box truck. A box truck is often cheaper than multiple van trips once you count mileage and time. See our complete DIY moving guide for sizing.

Tips for Loading a Cargo Van

  1. Put the heaviest items against the bulkhead behind the seats.
  2. Stack totes or boxes in tight rows, heaviest on the bottom.
  3. Stand mattresses on edge along one side.
  4. Use tie-down points and straps — vans have them on the floor and walls.
  5. Keep a clear line to the rear doors so the last-in items come out first.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is a cargo van big enough to move a studio apartment?

Often, yes — especially if you pack in uniform containers and have only a bed, a small sofa and a few pieces of furniture.

Can you move a mattress in a cargo van?

Yes. Stand it on its long edge along one wall and strap it in place.

Is a pickup truck good for moving?

For a few bulky items on a dry day, yes. For a full apartment, an enclosed van or box truck is safer and holds more.

How many moving totes fit in a cargo van?

It depends on the van size and furniture, but uniform totes stacked four to five high can fill most of a van's floor space efficiently.

Whatever you drive, pack in containers that stack. Nice Totes delivers 27-gallon totes, a dolly and free pickup across Chicago's north and northwest suburbs and southeast Wisconsin.

View Residential Pricing

Questions about sizing, coverage, or what's included? Check our FAQ page or email info@nicetotesrental.com.

Ready to Book Your Totes?

Free delivery, free pickup, and one dolly included with every package.

Book Now